Will Trump be impeached and removed from office?
The chance of Trump being impeached and removed from office before the end of the term is low, but not zero. I estimate roughly 8%, well below the market’s 16% price.
Analysis
The core obstacle is structural: impeachment is possible with a simple House majority, but removal requires a two-thirds Senate vote, which is historically rare and politically difficult even in highly charged conditions. Trump has already demonstrated unusual resilience to scandal and partisan pressure, and absent a major, sustained constitutional crisis, the Senate threshold remains the main bottleneck. A serious legal or investigative development could create impeachment momentum, but removal is a much higher bar than impeachment alone, so the event should be priced as an extreme-tail outcome rather than a plausible central case.
There are still meaningful paths to Yes. If a major national security, corruption, or criminal scandal emerges with broad bipartisan outrage, House impeachment could happen quickly, and a Senate conviction becomes conceivable if the evidence is overwhelming and the political environment shifts sharply. Trump’s political style also increases tail risk because he tends to generate conflicts that can escalate into formal proceedings. Even so, conviction would require substantial Republican defection, which is rare unless public opinion and elite consensus move dramatically against him.
Compared with the current 16% market price, the market looks too high. A price in the mid-teens implies a relatively material chance of both impeachment and the far harder step of removal, but historical precedent and current institutional incentives suggest that combination is still unlikely. The market may be overweighing headline risk and Trump-specific volatility while underweighting the Senate supermajority requirement, making the No side more attractive than the quote suggests.
Arguments
For
- Arguments for Yes: Trump’s high-conflict presidency creates an elevated risk of an event serious enough to trigger impeachment proceedings.
- Arguments for Yes: If evidence of major wrongdoing becomes overwhelming, bipartisan pressure could produce a rare Senate conviction.
Against
- Arguments against Yes: Senate removal is exceptionally hard and has almost never happened in U.S. history.
- Arguments against Yes: Partisan polarization makes it unlikely that enough senators from his own party would vote to convict.
Key drivers
- Removal requires a two-thirds Senate conviction, which is the decisive bottleneck.
- A major bipartisan scandal or constitutional crisis could rapidly change the political calculus.
Risk factors
- Trump’s history of generating severe controversies increases the odds of an impeachment attempt.
- A large shift in Senate composition or party discipline could make an otherwise remote conviction more plausible.
Scenarios
Best case
A major scandal or constitutional crisis creates bipartisan consensus, the House impeaches, and enough senators defect to remove Trump before the term ends.
Most likely
Trump faces repeated controversies and possibly investigative or impeachment threats, but the Senate never reaches the supermajority needed for removal.
Worst case
Trump remains politically intact through the end of the term, with no impeachment or with impeachment failing to reach Senate conviction.
More from this day
- economyPolymarket3mo
How many Fed rate cuts in 2026?
AI11%MKT93%Edge-82HypedI think there is still a meaningful chance of at least one Fed cut in 2026, but the market is pricing in a very strong hold case for a reason. My estimate is that there is about an 11% chance of no rate cuts at all in 2026.
- techPolymarket3mo
How many more Millennium Prize Problems will AI solve in 2026?
AI88%MKT19%Edge+69Hidden GemI think there is a strong chance that no qualifying Millennium Prize Problems will be counted for 2026 under this market’s rules, even though OpenAI’s Navier-Stokes claim makes the broader “AI solved a Millennium Problem” narrative look more plausible. The exclusion of Navier-Stokes from resolution is the key reason the zero-solved outcome still looks likelier than not.
- FinancialsKalshi13y
Will OpenAI or Anthropic IPO first?
AI34%MKT95%Edge-61HypedMy independent view is that OpenAI is less likely than the market implies to be the first of the two to IPO. The current reporting tilt favors Anthropic moving earlier, and OpenAI’s process appears more valuation- and timing-constrained.