Will President Trump be impeached during his term?
Trump has a meaningful path to a third impeachment if Democrats retake the House in 2026 or if a major scandal energizes a majority, but the current Congress is still not there. I put the odds modestly below the market because the House vote just showed support is real but not yet close to a winning coalition.
Analysis
The strongest case for impeachment is procedural rather than substantive: there is still ample time before January 2029, Trump has already been impeached twice, and the House just showed a sizeable minority willing to support a new impeachment effort. That means the topic is not fringe, and if the political environment changes after the 2026 midterms, a majority could emerge quickly. In a polarized era, impeachment is often driven less by new evidence than by which party controls the House and whether leadership decides the issue is worth the fight.
The strongest case against impeachment is that the current House vote was not close to advancing articles, and leadership chose to table the resolution. That suggests the present Congress does not have the votes, and impeachment would require either a Democratic House majority or a major shock that changes member incentives. Even then, impeachment is a high-cost vote, so many members would need to believe the political and evidentiary case is overwhelming enough to justify it.
Compared with the market price, I think 67% is somewhat too aggressive. The market seems to be pricing in a fairly high probability that Democrats win the House and then decide to impeach, but that chain still requires multiple steps to break right. A price in the low 60s better reflects the combination of time remaining, a plausible but not assured House flip, and the fact that the current impeachment push has support but not a majority.
Arguments
For
- A House majority change in 2026 would reopen a clear institutional path to impeachment.
- There is already a visible bloc of members willing to support articles, indicating the issue has live political traction.
Against
- The most recent House vote showed the resolution could not even clear a tabling motion, which is a weak starting point.
- Impeachment requires sustained leadership commitment and political coordination, both of which remain uncertain.
Key drivers
- The 2026 midterm House outcome is the main gating factor for any successful new impeachment effort.
- Trump’s prior impeachments show the mechanism is politically familiar and not a theoretical edge case.
- The recent floor vote revealed real internal Democratic support, even though it fell far short of passage.
Risk factors
- Republicans may retain the House, which would make impeachment highly unlikely.
- Even with Democratic control, leadership may decide impeachment is politically too risky or distracting.
- A competing scandal or legislative agenda could crowd out impeachment and reduce urgency.
Scenarios
Best case
Democrats win the House in 2026, leadership decides Trump’s conduct warrants action, and articles are approved in 2027 or 2028, making impeachment almost certain.
Most likely
The current Congress continues blocking impeachment, the 2026 midterms determine whether the issue becomes viable, and impeachment only happens if Democrats win the House and prioritize it over other agenda items.
Worst case
Republicans keep the House or Democrats avoid the fight, so no impeachment resolution ever advances beyond symbolic efforts.
More from this day
- FinancialsKalshi13y
Will OpenAI or Anthropic IPO first?
AI14%MKT91%Edge-77HypedI think the more likely outcome is that Anthropic goes public before OpenAI, so I put the Yes side at a low probability. OpenAI’s public comments and the current reporting both point to Anthropic having the earlier path to listing.
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
"Resident Evil" Opening Weekend Box Office
AI58%MKT2%Edge+56Hidden GemI think there is a modest edge to the opening weekend finishing under $50 million, but it is far from certain. The current tracking cluster sits close to the line, so a result just above or just below $50 million remains the most plausible range.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Who will Trump pardon?
AI2%MKT50%Edge-48HypedI put the chance of Barron Trump receiving a presidential pardon before Jan. 21, 2029 at 2%. There is no visible legal predicate for a pardon, and absent a federal case or at least a credible public controversy, the event is extremely unlikely.