Who will be Trump's next Press Secretary?
Maria Bartiromo is a plausible Trump-aligned media figure, but she is not the most likely choice for a demanding, low-pay, high-friction briefing role. I put her at about 12%, well below the market’s 21%.
Analysis
With no fresh news, this is mostly a structural hire question: Trump tends to favor loyalists who are either already inside his political orbit or have proven they can absorb daily message discipline without disrupting a lucrative outside career. Bartiromo clearly fits the loyalty and media-recognition profile, but she is also one of the highest-value on-air personalities in conservative media, which makes the tradeoff of leaving Fox for a volatile White House post a meaningful hurdle. The job is less about being famous on television and more about absorbing constant scrutiny, coordinating across the West Wing, and sustaining a punishing daily grind, so the ideal candidate is usually an operative with very strong Trump alignment and lower opportunity cost.
Compared with the market, the 21% price on Bartiromo looks a bit rich. The market is likely overweighting headline familiarity and the intuitive appeal of putting a well-known TV personality at the podium, but the more probable outcome is that Trump chooses someone with tighter internal political utility and greater willingness to take the role, such as Scott Jennings, Anna Kelly, or Danielle Alvarez. Bartiromo is credible enough that she cannot be dismissed, but I would treat her as a secondary contender rather than the frontrunner, making the current market price look somewhat inflated.
Arguments
For
- Arguments for Yes: She is a well-known conservative media figure who can handle hostile questioning on camera.
- Arguments for Yes: Her public alignment with Trump makes her an intuitive fit for a loyalty-first personnel choice.
Against
- Arguments against Yes: The job is operationally grueling and usually better suited to an insider or disciplined political communicator than a top-tier TV host.
- Arguments against Yes: Her outside career likely pays far more than a press secretary role, reducing the odds she would actually accept.
Key drivers
- Trump is more likely to prioritize loyalty and message discipline than pure celebrity when filling a communications role.
- Bartiromo's high-profile media career creates a large opportunity-cost barrier to taking a difficult government job.
Risk factors
- Trump could still make a showy, media-forward pick if he wants a headline-grabbing press secretary.
- If Bartiromo is already privately engaged in conversations with the transition team, her probability could rise quickly.
Scenarios
Best case
Trump wants a high-visibility, cable-news-ready face for the role and Bartiromo is willing to leave Fox for a prominent White House position.
Most likely
Bartiromo remains in the broader conversation but a closer Trump-aligned operative with lower opportunity cost and higher day-to-day manageability wins the job.
Worst case
Trump chooses a more operationally useful insider or strategist, leaving Bartiromo as a named but ultimately non-selected finalist.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Maria Bartiromo | 12% | 21% |
| Scott Jennings | 30% | 20% |
| Anna Kelly | 28% | 18% |
| Danielle Alvarez | 22% | 14% |
| Alina Habba | 8% | 5% |
More from this day
- FinancialsKalshi13y
Will OpenAI or Anthropic IPO first?
AI18%MKT91%Edge-73HypedI think the Yes side is materially overvalued if Yes means OpenAI goes public before Anthropic. The public reporting currently points more strongly to Anthropic moving first, with OpenAI signaling a later 2027 timeframe.
- PoliticsKalshi1y
Which state will vote first in the 2028 Democratic presidential primary?
AI33%MKT89%Edge-56HypedThe evidence favors New Hampshire not being the first Democratic contest in 2028. Recent calendar reporting points to South Carolina first, with New Hampshire early but not earliest.
- pop culturePolymarketTomorrow
"Resident Evil" Opening Weekend Box Office
AI82%MKT27%Edge+55Hidden GemResident Evil is much more likely than not to open below 50 million domestically. The franchise has strong recognition, but this threshold is high enough that only a breakout, four-quadrant launch would clear it.