Will Trump abolish the Department of Education?
I put the chance of the Department of Education being fully eliminated by January 20, 2029 at about 10%. Trump could weaken or restructure it substantially, but outright abolition requires a level of congressional cooperation that remains unlikely.
Analysis
The key constraint is legal rather than rhetorical: a president cannot simply abolish a cabinet department by executive action alone. Fully eliminating the Department of Education would almost certainly require new legislation, and that means overcoming both ordinary congressional politics and, in practice, the Senate filibuster unless Senate rules change. That makes the base rate for total abolition very low even when a president is ideologically aligned with the goal.
There are still real arguments for a nontrivial yes probability. Trump has repeatedly signaled hostility to the department, and a Republican-controlled government could try to package abolition or a major transfer of functions into a broader reform bill. If the GOP were to gain unified control and decide to spend political capital on this issue, it is at least possible that a weakened department could be dismantled on paper, especially if the legislative environment becomes unusually favorable.
Compared with that legal and political reality, the current market price of 16% looks somewhat high. The market seems to be pricing the chance of aggressive executive action, partisan momentum, and the possibility of Congress cooperating more than history would suggest. I think the better estimate is closer to 10%, because the most likely outcome is not elimination but continued pressure, budget cuts, and administrative churn without formal abolition.
Arguments
For
- Trump has publicly favored shrinking or eliminating the Department of Education, so the administration would likely push in that direction.
- If Republicans maintain unified control and bypass internal resistance, a legislative abolition effort is at least conceivable.
Against
- A president cannot abolish a federal department unilaterally, and Congress has to enact the change.
- The Senate filibuster and competing legislative priorities make total abolition much less likely than partial restructuring.
Key drivers
- Abolition requires legislation, not just presidential action, which creates a major procedural barrier.
- Republican control of Congress and willingness to spend political capital on the issue could raise the odds from near-zero to modest.
Risk factors
- A midterm or post-midterm shift in congressional control could make legislation harder than expected.
- The market may overestimate the chance that symbolic executive moves count as actual elimination.
Scenarios
Best case
Trump and congressional Republicans coordinate on legislation that formally eliminates the department and redistributes its core functions before January 2029.
Most likely
The Department of Education remains legally in place, while the administration pursues cuts, deregulatory changes, and possible transfer of selected functions.
Worst case
The department survives intact, with only rhetorical attacks, budget pressure, personnel changes, or limited administrative restructuring.
More from this day
- FinancialsKalshi13y
Will OpenAI or Anthropic IPO first?
AI24%MKT94%Edge-70HypedI think Anthropic is more likely to IPO before OpenAI, so if the market is asking whether OpenAI goes first, my answer is no more often than yes. Recent reporting has shifted the lead toward Anthropic, while OpenAI looks more likely to wait for a better valuation and a calmer market.
- CompaniesKalshi1y
Starbucks total global stores in 2026
AI68%MKT15%Edge+53Hidden GemStarbucks is more likely than not to finish 2026 above 41,800 global stores. The threshold is only modestly above its last known scale, and ordinary net expansion should get it there unless management materially slows growth or closes a large number of stores.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Which agencies will Trump eliminate?
AI74%MKT30%Edge+44Hidden GemUSAID already looks functionally dismantled, with most staff, projects, and operational authority stripped away. The main uncertainty is whether the market resolves on de facto elimination or requires formal statutory abolition, but I still see a Yes outcome as more likely than not.