Will Trump be impeached and removed from office?
I assess the chance of Trump being both impeached and removed before the end of his term as quite low, around 6%. The latest House vote to table an impeachment resolution reinforces that removal would require a major political shift plus a Senate conviction that remains structurally difficult.
Analysis
The core obstacle is not whether an impeachment resolution can be introduced, but whether it can survive the political incentives required to reach removal. The House has already shown it is not close to advancing a new impeachment effort, with the Sept. 15 tabling vote indicating weak appetite even among Democrats. More importantly, removal requires a two-thirds Senate conviction, and there is no sign of a coalition remotely near that threshold unless there is a dramatic deterioration in Trump’s standing or a major shift in chamber control after the next election.
Historically, impeachment is possible even in polarized conditions, but removal is rare and usually depends on overwhelming bipartisan consensus or an extraordinary scandal. Trump’s first-term impeachments are relevant mainly as proof that the House can act, not as evidence that the Senate would convict; both prior efforts failed at the removal stage. The current environment looks even less favorable than those episodes because the latest push appears to be symbolic, deferred for investigations, and politically unsustained.
Against the current market price, I think 18% is too high for the combined outcome of impeachment and removal. A market price that elevated may be pricing in tail risk from unexpected legal or political shocks, but the baseline path still points to a House that is unlikely to impeach and a Senate that is much less likely to convict. On the facts provided, the market seems to be overestimating the odds of a full removal sequence rather than just a House impeachment vote.
Arguments
For
- Arguments for Yes: Trump has already faced impeachment twice, so the House has precedent for moving quickly if political pressure spikes.
- Arguments for Yes: A severe enough scandal or collapse in support could create bipartisan momentum that is currently absent.
Against
- Arguments against Yes: The House recently tabled a new impeachment resolution, showing little current institutional appetite for action.
- Arguments against Yes: Even if impeached, removal would still require a two-thirds Senate conviction, which is historically and politically very unlikely.
Key drivers
- The House has just rejected the latest impeachment push, signaling weak current momentum.
- Removal requires a two-thirds Senate conviction, which is an extremely high bar under present partisan conditions.
Risk factors
- A major scandal, criminal revelation, or constitutional crisis could rapidly change congressional incentives.
- Control of the House after the next election could create a new impeachment path if public opinion shifts sharply.
Scenarios
Best case
A major new controversy, combined with a change in House control or a dramatic political realignment, leads to impeachment and an unusually large bipartisan Senate break toward conviction.
Most likely
There may be periodic impeachment talk or symbolic resolutions, but the House does not advance a serious case and the Senate never comes close to the votes needed for removal.
Worst case
Trump remains politically protected enough that no serious impeachment advances, and he serves out the rest of the term without even reaching a viable Senate removal process.
More from this day
- PoliticsKalshi1y
2026: Trump's bad year?
AI71%MKT7%Edge+64Hidden GemTrump looks more likely than not to have a clearly negative 2026 by the market’s own bear-case standard: repeated legal setbacks, court limits, and headline damage are already piling up. The market appears to be pricing an almost-no-risk outcome despite a year that is structurally set up for more confrontation and reversals.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Who will be Trump's next Secretary of Labor?
AI35%MKT97%Edge-62HypedKeith Sonderling is the most plausible listed contender only because he is the acting secretary, but the reporting points more strongly to Lori Chavez-DeRemer as the actual next Labor Secretary. That makes Sonderling a much weaker favorite than the market suggests.
- techPolymarket3mo
AI wins IMO gold medal in 2026?
AI58%MKT10%Edge+48Hidden GemThe odds of a Yes outcome look materially higher than the current market price because there is already a reported 2026 system score at the stated gold threshold, and only a limited amount of time remains for the relevant sources to formalize or publicize a qualifying result. Still, the biggest uncertainty is whether the market settles on a demonstrated benchmark result or an officially recognized competition outcome.