Which Supreme Court justices will resign during Trump's term?
I think Alito is materially less likely than the market to resign during Trump’s term. His public denial of retirement rumors, the absence of any confirmed intent to step down, and the strong incentives for justices to remain on the Court all point to a low-to-moderate probability rather than a coin flip-plus event.
Analysis
Samuel Alito has strong structural reasons not to resign in the next few years. Supreme Court justices hold lifetime tenure, and for a justice with a clear ideological stake in the Court’s direction, stepping down is usually a deliberate strategic choice rather than something that happens casually. The recent reporting provided here is also directionally negative for a resignation: the clearest direct evidence is that Alito publicly denied retirement rumors and said he would be there for the next term, which is the opposite of a near-term departure signal.
The strongest case for a resignation is not evidence of intent, but uncertainty. Alito is in his mid-70s, and the remaining term is long enough for health, family, or a sudden strategic calculation to change the picture. Public speculation around high-profile justices can also be self-reinforcing, especially when the Court remains central to political and legal disputes. Still, speculation is not the same as demonstrated willingness to step aside, and the provided material explicitly says there is no confirmed plan to resign.
Against the current market price of 0.64, this looks expensive. A 64% implied probability would make resignation seem more likely than not, but the actual evidence here is thin and mostly points the other way. Unless there is private information not reflected in the public reporting, the market appears to be overweighting age, general churn risk, and generic Supreme Court succession narratives relative to Alito’s own stated position and the low baseline rate of voluntary resignations.
I would price this closer to the low 20s, with the main reason for any upside being an unexpected health or personal-development event rather than any present indication that resignation is imminent.
Arguments
For
- Age and the finite remaining Trump term create a meaningful chance of an eventual exit.
- High-profile justices sometimes time departures strategically, and future political conditions could change Alito’s incentives.
Against
- He has publicly denied retirement rumors and said he would be there for the next term.
- There is no confirmed reporting of an intention to resign, and voluntary Supreme Court resignations remain uncommon.
Key drivers
- Alito has publicly denied retirement rumors, which is the most direct evidence available about his near-term intentions.
- The remaining window is only a few years, so age and health create some nonzero but still limited departure risk.
Risk factors
- A private health issue or family circumstance could prompt an unanticipated resignation at any time.
- The market may be aware of information or soft signals not captured in the public reporting provided here.
Scenarios
Best case
Alito surprises the market by announcing retirement or resignation during the term, likely after a private health, family, or strategic development.
Most likely
Alito remains on the Court for now, with resignation risk limited to an unanticipated future event rather than any current indication of imminent departure.
Worst case
He stays on the Court through the end of Trump’s term and the market’s resignation thesis never materializes.
More from this day
- pop culturePolymarket11d
"Spider-Man: Brand New Day" total domestic gross by September 30?
AI99%MKT2%Edge+97Hidden GemSpider-Man: Brand New Day finishing below 940m domestic by September 30 looks overwhelmingly likely. The threshold is so high that only an extreme, record-breaking performance would threaten it.
- pop culturePolymarket3mo
Where will 2026 rank among the hottest years on record?
AI18%MKT75%Edge-57Hyped2026 is more likely than not to fall short of being the single hottest year on record. The market appears to be pricing in a continuation of extreme global warmth, but the odds still favor at least one other year, especially 2024 or 2025, finishing hotter on the NASA index.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Who will Trump pardon?
AI4%MKT51%Edge-47HypedI estimate Barron Trump’s chance of receiving a presidential pardon before January 21, 2029 at very low, around 4%. Absent a specific federal criminal exposure or public controversy, there is little reason to expect a pardon for a private family member.