Who will leave Trump's Cabinet next?
Pete Hegseth is a meaningful but not dominant candidate to be the next Cabinet departure. I put his chance at 20%, above the market, because his role is highly exposed to scandal and operational scrutiny, though RFK Jr. and Susie Wiles look slightly more vulnerable overall.
Analysis
With no fresh news to anchor the forecast, the best way to price this event is by structural fragility: which cabinet member is most likely to become politically inconvenient, burn out, or be forced out by a crisis. On that basis, Hegseth belongs in the upper tier because defense is a visible, high-stakes portfolio where personnel missteps, discipline issues, or clashes with the Pentagon can quickly become existential. Still, he is not an obvious frontrunner, because the most vulnerable next exit often comes from the person whose job is hardest to sustain, not simply the one with the loudest controversies.
Hegseth’s case for leaving first is that he sits in a role where every controversy is amplified and where Trump could decide that a loyalty problem or management failure is no longer worth the cost. The case against him is that Trump often tolerates turbulence from loyal, combative appointees, especially when they are useful as public warriors. That makes Hegseth more likely than the market implies, but not enough to make him the favorite over the broader field.
Relative to the current market, 14% looks a bit low for Hegseth, mainly because the market appears to be spreading risk across a crowded set of alternatives. My independent view is that Hegseth is one of the more exposed names, but the presence of RFK Jr. and Susie Wiles as similarly plausible exit candidates limits his share of the total. In other words, the market is probably underweighting his specific fragility, though it is not wildly off given how competitive the field is.
Arguments
For
- He occupies a highly exposed post where public and congressional pressure can escalate quickly.
- Trump has a history of replacing cabinet figures once they become politically burdensome.
Against
- Loyalty can outweigh controversy in Trump’s personnel decisions, and Hegseth may benefit from that dynamic.
- RFK Jr. and Susie Wiles have stronger structural reasons to depart first, which caps Hegseth’s probability.
Key drivers
- Defense is one of the most scrutinized cabinet posts, so even a modest scandal can become a fast exit trigger.
- Trump may prefer to keep a loyal, combative figure in place unless the political cost becomes undeniable.
- Competing vulnerability among RFK Jr. and Susie Wiles prevents Hegseth from being a clear favorite.
Risk factors
- No material scandal or management failure emerges before another contender leaves first.
- Trump continues to value Hegseth as a loyal media and culture-war asset despite the noise around him.
Scenarios
Best case
A public scandal, management breakdown, or civil-military clash makes Hegseth a liability and he is removed or resigns before other vulnerable cabinet figures.
Most likely
Hegseth remains under recurring scrutiny but survives the next stretch, while the next departure is more likely to come from RFK Jr. or Susie Wiles.
Worst case
He stays in place while RFK Jr., Susie Wiles, or another contender exits first, making the Yes side look too aggressive.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Pete Hegseth | 20% | 14% |
| Markwayne Mullin | 8% | 14% |
| Chris Wright | 14% | 14% |
| Robert F. Kennedy Jr. | 33% | 12% |
| Susie Wiles | 25% | 6% |
More from this day
- economyPolymarket3mo
Will Stripe acquire any part of Paypal in 2026?
AI7%MKT67%Edge-60HypedI think a Stripe acquisition of any part of PayPal in 2026 is very unlikely, despite the market pricing it as a strong possibility. The main reason is that this would be a large, strategically odd, and likely antitrust-sensitive transaction with little visible evidence supporting it.
- FinancialsKalshi13y
Will OpenAI or Anthropic IPO first?
AI38%MKT93%Edge-55HypedI think OpenAI is substantially less likely than the market implies to IPO before Anthropic. The stronger read from the current evidence is that Anthropic has a modest but real timing edge, so I price the Yes outcome well below the market.
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
"Spider-Man: Brand New Day" 3rd Weekend Box Office (Lower Strikes)
AI64%MKT10%Edge+54Hidden GemA third weekend above 66 million is a very high bar, even for Spider-Man, so I lean toward Yes. The main reason to doubt that view is that this franchise can occasionally hold far better than a normal blockbuster if audience demand stays unusually strong.