Will Trump be impeached and removed from office?
I put the chance at about 8%, materially below the market. Impeachment is plausible if political conditions sour, but actual removal would require a much rarer cross-party collapse in the Senate.
Analysis
The core issue is that this market requires both impeachment and removal, and removal is the real bottleneck. Even in highly polarized conditions, a president usually only falls if there is an extraordinary scandal, clear criminal exposure, or a broad bipartisan conviction that the office can no longer be defended. By historical standards, that is a very high bar, and Trump’s prior impeachments show that even intense political conflict does not automatically translate into removal.
There is a plausible path to impeachment if the House flips or if there is a major midterm backlash, but impeachment alone is not enough for a yes outcome. The Senate would still need a two-thirds vote for conviction, which means a meaningful number of Republicans would have to defect. That is possible only under a severe, widely documented crisis; otherwise party loyalty and fear of electoral blowback usually keep the threshold out of reach.
Against the current market price of 19%, this looks overstated. The market may be pricing in generic Trump volatility and conflating “impeached” with “removed,” but the event resolves only if both occur. With no specific recent scandal provided, the base-rate answer is that removal before January 2029 remains unlikely, even if political turbulence creates periodic spikes in risk.
Arguments
For
- Trump remains unusually polarizing and has a history of drawing impeachment-level conflict.
- If Democrats gain control of the House and uncover severe wrongdoing, impeachment could happen and keep the removal pathway alive.
Against
- The Senate conviction threshold is extremely high and has almost never been met in modern U.S. politics.
- Absent a uniquely severe scandal, the more likely outcomes are litigation, political damage, or electoral defeat rather than removal.
Key drivers
- Removal requires a two-thirds Senate conviction, which is historically far harder than impeachment.
- A 2026 House flip could make impeachment plausible, but it does not by itself make the yes outcome likely.
Risk factors
- A major constitutional crisis or explosive misconduct revelation could fracture Republican Senate support.
- Unexpected health, legal, or national-security developments could rapidly increase the odds of conviction.
Scenarios
Best case
A major scandal emerges, the House impeaches, and enough Republican senators break ranks to convict, producing removal before the term ends.
Most likely
Trump faces recurring controversy and possible impeachment pressure, but the Senate never reaches the conviction threshold, so he remains in office until the term ends or leaves for other reasons not counted as removal.
Worst case
No new scandal materializes, Trump survives the term politically, and the market resolves No.
More from this day
- cryptoPolymarket3mo
Will Anthropic flip BTC by December 31?
AI2%MKT77%Edge-75HypedAnthropic flipping Bitcoin by the end of 2026 looks extraordinarily unlikely. The valuation gap is so large that it would likely require a once-in-a-generation private funding event for Anthropic and a major Bitcoin drawdown at the same time.
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
"Spider-Man: Brand New Day" total domestic gross by August 31? (Higher Strikes)
AI25%MKT84%Edge-59HypedMy read is that Spider-Man: Brand New Day is more likely to finish above 900M domestically by August 31 than below it. I put the chance of less than 900M at about 25%, because the film is already so far along that only an unusually sharp slowdown would keep it under the line.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Which agencies will Trump eliminate?
AI74%MKT30%Edge+44Hidden GemUSAID already looks functionally dismantled, with most staff, projects, and operational authority stripped away. The main uncertainty is whether the market resolves on de facto elimination or requires formal statutory abolition, but I still see a Yes outcome as more likely than not.