Who will leave Trump's Cabinet next?
RFK Jr. is the single most plausible next Cabinet departure, but the odds are still only moderately above even because there is no confirmed firing or resignation. I put the chance he is next at 34%, slightly above the market.
Analysis
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has the strongest case for being the next Cabinet member to leave because the reporting shows real friction with Trump over vaccines and autism policy, plus signs that Trump has at least informally contemplated a replacement path. The references to Mehmet Oz being groomed as a possible successor matter because they are the clearest evidence that this is not just abstract speculation; there is some contingency planning behind the scenes. HHS instability and staff churn add to the sense that his department is the most fragile political environment among the leading contenders.
The main argument against a higher probability is that Kennedy still appears tenable and there is no confirmed departure signal. Trump may actually tolerate him longer than a more conventional appointee because Kennedy fits parts of Trump’s anti-establishment and anti-vaccine posture, and that overlap can reduce the likelihood of a sudden firing. In other words, the same controversy that creates vulnerability also gives him some insulation, since Trump may prefer keeping an unconventional ally in place rather than triggering a messy replacement fight.
Compared with the rest of the field, RFK looks more exposed than Chris Wright, Brooke Rollins, and probably Markwayne Mullin, while Pete Hegseth appears the main alternative threat because his own profile is also politically volatile. The current 29% market price looks a bit low to me given the combination of reported replacement chatter and department instability, but not dramatically so because the absence of a confirmed break means timing remains uncertain. This is a real lead, not a conviction trade; the market is probably understating RFK’s vulnerability by a few points rather than by a wide margin.
Arguments
For
- Arguments for Yes: He has the clearest visible tension with Trump and the most explicit replacement speculation.
- Arguments for Yes: HHS instability and staff churn make his department look more likely than others to produce an early exit.
Against
- Arguments against Yes: The latest reporting does not show an imminent departure, only growing speculation.
- Arguments against Yes: Trump may see value in keeping Kennedy in place because their messaging overlaps on key issues.
Key drivers
- Trump's frustration over vaccine and autism policy creates a concrete source of conflict with Kennedy.
- Reported successor grooming, especially around Mehmet Oz, is the strongest sign that a replacement scenario is being considered.
Risk factors
- Kennedy still appears willing to stay, and there is no confirmed firing or resignation.
- Trump may keep him because Kennedy remains useful for anti-establishment messaging and vaccine rhetoric.
Scenarios
Best case
The vaccine-policy fight escalates, Trump loses patience, and Mehmet Oz or another successor is publicly positioned, making Kennedy the next Cabinet exit.
Most likely
Kennedy remains under pressure and is a live replacement candidate, but no immediate dismissal occurs, leaving the next departure race open and only modestly favoring him.
Worst case
Kennedy survives the current tension, the HHS turmoil stabilizes, and another Cabinet member with a bigger scandal or weaker protection leaves first.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Robert F. Kennedy Jr. | 34% | 29% |
| Chris Wright | 17% | 14% |
| Markwayne Mullin | 14% | 11% |
| Pete Hegseth | 21% | 10% |
| Brooke Rollins | 14% | 9% |
More from this day
- CompaniesKalshi1y
Starbucks total global stores in 2026
AI96%MKT9%Edge+87Hidden GemStarbucks is already above the 41,800-store threshold in its latest reported results, and management’s 2026 opening guidance makes an above-threshold 2026 report highly likely. I put the Yes probability at 96%.
- PoliticsKalshi1y
2026: Trump's bad year?
AI68%MKT10%Edge+58Hidden GemTrump already has multiple concrete 2026 setbacks in court, so the bear-case narrative looks more likely than not. The market’s 11% price appears too low unless the event definition is far narrower than the news flow suggests.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Who will Trump pardon?
AI3%MKT47%Edge-44HypedBarron Trump receiving a presidential pardon by Jan. 21, 2029 looks extremely unlikely absent some new federal legal exposure. My independent estimate is 3%, far below the current market price.