Will Trump be impeached and removed from office?
I put the chance that Trump is both impeached and removed from office before the end of the term at 11%. The recent impeachment talk is real, but the constitutional bar for removal is still extremely high and the current evidence shows only threats and filing efforts, not a completed path to conviction.
Analysis
The news flow shows renewed impeachment activity, but it is still at the level of proposals, rhetoric, and resolutions rather than actual House action. That matters a great deal because the event requires not just impeachment, but removal from office, which means a completed House vote and then a two-thirds Senate conviction. Based on what is provided, there is no concrete evidence yet that either chamber is close to crossing those thresholds.
Historically, presidential removal is extraordinarily difficult even when a president is deeply polarizing. Trump has already survived two impeachments without removal, which is a strong reminder that partisan alignment and Senate math usually protect a sitting president unless there is a truly overwhelming bipartisan collapse. With time still remaining in the term, there is some chance that a severe scandal or extraordinary abuse of power could shift the odds, but absent that kind of catalyst, the base rate remains very low.
The market at 19% looks somewhat rich relative to the facts provided. It appears to be pricing the possibility of more impeachment headlines as if they meaningfully translate into removal, but the Senate hurdle is the real bottleneck and there is no sign here that it has weakened. I would treat this as a market that is somewhat overestimating the probability of a full constitutional removal and underweighting how often impeachment efforts stall before reaching a vote.
Arguments
For
- Arguments for Yes: There is active impeachment organizing, which means the issue is politically alive and could advance if new evidence or events emerge.
- Arguments for Yes: Trump’s presidency is uniquely contentious, so an extraordinary scandal could create a bipartisan rupture that is rare but not impossible.
Against
- Arguments against Yes: The current reporting shows no confirmed House impeachment vote and no Senate removal process, only efforts and threats.
- Arguments against Yes: Even if the House impeaches, conviction requires two-thirds of the Senate, which is an exceptionally high barrier in a polarized environment.
Key drivers
- A House impeachment vote would still require a major political shift that is not yet visible in the evidence.
- Removal needs two-thirds of the Senate, which is the main structural obstacle and has historically been almost impossible to clear.
Risk factors
- A major future scandal, legal crisis, or national security incident could rapidly change congressional incentives.
- Midterm or special-election shifts could alter House and Senate control enough to make impeachment and conviction more plausible.
Scenarios
Best case
A major scandal or constitutional crisis triggers bipartisan support in the House and an unexpected Senate coalition forms, leading to impeachment and conviction before the term ends.
Most likely
There are more impeachment threats and possibly even procedural steps, but the process stalls before removal because the Senate remains far short of the votes needed.
Worst case
Impeachment talk continues as political messaging, but no House vote succeeds and the Senate never comes close to the supermajority needed for removal.
More from this day
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
"Spider-Man: Brand New Day" Opening Weekend Box Office (Higher Strikes)
AI84%MKT8%Edge+76Hidden GemMost credible domestic forecasts sit well below $280 million, so I think the under-threshold outcome is much more likely than the market price suggests. The main upside risk is that Spider-Man can still produce a record-level opening, but that would require a major surprise versus current tracking.
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
"Spider-Man: Brand New Day" Opening Day Box Office
AI73%MKT2%Edge+71Hidden GemThe current tracking suggests a very large opening, but not necessarily one large enough to clear 120m on the opening day figure used by this market. I think less than 120m is more likely than the market price implies, with the center of gravity in the low-to-mid 100s rather than comfortably above the line.
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
"The Odyssey" 3rd Weekend Box Office
AI71%MKT9%Edge+62Hidden GemThe latest box office tracking and industry forecasts point to a third weekend around the mid-40 millions, which puts the under-47m outcome in the lead. The market appears to be pricing in a meaningful chance of a stronger-than-expected hold, but the balance of evidence still favors Yes.