Who will be Trump's next Attorney General?
Todd Blanche remains the clear favorite because he is already the nominee and is serving as acting attorney general, but the confirmation path is not risk-free. I put the independent probability that Blanche ends up as Trump's next confirmed attorney general materially below the market's implied certainty, though still high.
Analysis
The strongest argument for Blanche is structural: he is already the named nominee and is currently operating as acting attorney general, which gives Trump a clean continuity option and makes Blanche the most administratively straightforward choice. Recent reporting also frames him as the frontrunner, and Politico specifically noted that his qualifications and reputation would likely help him get swift confirmation. In a market like this, incumbent status in the acting role is meaningful because it reduces the need for a fresh political search and signals that Trump has already settled on him as the preferred candidate.
The main reason to discount absolute confidence is that confirmation still requires Senate passage, and the reporting in the prompt points to real resistance from key Republicans. Coverage describing a narrow Judiciary Committee margin and possible wavering from senators such as Cornyn and Tillis indicates that Blanche is not a lock, especially if Democrats uniformly oppose him. The hearing coverage also suggests substantive scrutiny over DOJ politicization, the Epstein files, and Blanche's closeness to Trump, which are exactly the kinds of issues that can turn a nominee into a confirmation casualty even when the president strongly prefers him.
Against the smaller alternatives, Blanche still looks much more likely than anyone else named here. Lee Zeldin appears to have been a serious contender in earlier chatter, but the current reporting in the prompt centers the process on Blanche as the nominee rather than a live replacement hunt. Jeanine Pirro, Ron DeSantis, and Harmeet Dhillon are all plausible political names, but none has the same combination of being formally nominated, already installed in the acting role, and publicly treated as the current path of least resistance.
The market price of 87% for Blanche looks somewhat too high to me because it appears to price in confirmation as close to a foregone conclusion, while the reporting still leaves room for a Senate setback or an abrupt Trump reversal if resistance hardens. That said, I do think Blanche is the most likely outcome by a wide margin, so the market is probably directionally right but a bit overconfident on the exact probability. My read is that the probability of Blanche prevailing is high, but not high enough to justify the near-certain pricing implied by the current market share.
Arguments
For
- Arguments for Yes: Blanche is the sitting acting attorney general and the publicly identified nominee, so the institutional path strongly favors him.
- Arguments for Yes: He has enough prosecutorial and defense experience to be defensible as a qualified choice, which helps his confirmation case.
Against
- Arguments against Yes: Key Senate Republicans have reportedly signaled hesitation, and a narrow margin means a few defections could sink him.
- Arguments against Yes: Trump has other politically aligned options, so a failed or delayed confirmation could lead him to switch nominees.
Key drivers
- Blanche is already the nominee and is serving as acting attorney general, which makes him the default continuity choice.
- Senate confirmation risk remains real because even a few GOP defections could matter in a close committee and floor process.
Risk factors
- Trump could pivot to another loyalist if Blanche's confirmation prospects deteriorate.
- A Senate rejection or prolonged stalemate would keep the field open for a different nominee or acting arrangement.
Scenarios
Best case
Blanche is confirmed after enough Republican senators fall in line, making him Trump's next confirmed attorney general before Jan. 20, 2029.
Most likely
Blanche remains the frontrunner and probably gets across the finish line, but the confirmation process is sufficiently contested that the outcome is less certain than the market suggests.
Worst case
Senate resistance blocks Blanche, Trump abandons the nomination, and another figure such as Zeldin or a different loyalist becomes the next confirmed attorney general.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Todd Blanche | 68% | 87% |
| Lee Zeldin | 12% | 5% |
| Jeanine Pirro | 7% | 2% |
| Ron DeSantis | 5% | 2% |
| Harmeet Dhillon | 4% | 1% |
More from this day
- politicsPolymarket9d
Iran leadership change by...?
AI86%MKT13%Edge+73Hidden GemThe market looks heavily tilted toward Yes because the supplied reporting already indicates that Iran’s top leadership has changed, with Mojtaba Khamenei named as supreme leader or, at minimum, the old leadership structure replaced by an interim council. The main uncertainty is definitional, but under the market’s broad language a Yes outcome is more likely than the current price suggests.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Who will Trump pardon?
AI8%MKT51%Edge-43HypedI assess a low but nonzero chance that Barron Trump receives a presidential pardon before Jan. 21, 2029, because there is no known underlying criminal case that would make a pardon necessary. The market’s near-even price looks materially too high for a normal pardon outcome.
- PoliticsKalshi1y
2026: Trump's bad year?
AI58%MKT15%Edge+43Hidden GemI make the bear-case outcome moderately likely in 2026, at about 58%, because Trump is facing a growing stack of high-salience legal and institutional reversals rather than a single isolated controversy. The market’s 13% Yes price looks far too low if the event is defined as meaningful negative developments occurring during the year.