Who will be Trump's next Attorney General?
Todd Blanche is Trump's nominated Attorney General and has completed his Senate hearing, but faces a narrow path to confirmation due to potential Republican holdouts like Sen. Tillis; despite market overconfidence at 81%, his independent probability of confirmation is 68%.
Analysis
Todd Blanche has officially been nominated by Trump for permanent Attorney General and served in an acting capacity since April 2, 2026, with his two-day Senate Judiciary Committee hearing concluding on July 16, 2026. The hearing featured tough questioning from Democrats and some Republicans over his ties to Trump, subpoena attempts against Times journalists, DOJ independence, and the Epstein investigation, leaving his confirmation unassured despite his prior confirmation as Deputy AG in March 2025. Blanche needs all Republican votes on the Judiciary Committee to advance, and on the full Senate floor he can lose only three Republican votes given uniform Democratic opposition, creating a razor-thin margin where a single holdout like Sen. Thom Tillis—who demands a meeting with Epstein survivors—could block committee advancement.
The primary risk is Republican defection, with roughly 1,200 DOJ alumni signing a letter demanding rejection and bar disciplinary referrals for Blanche over improper judicial process manipulation for Trump's tax immunity. While groups like TABS endorse him for border enforcement continuity, the combination of Tillis's conditional vote, potential Cornyn hesitation, and the Epstein file controversy creates genuine uncertainty that prediction markets are underweighting. Kalshi contracts showed only ~3% implied probability for Blanche as of July 13, reflecting this Senate clearance risk, while Polymarket's 48% for Zeldin and 18% for Blanche suggest the market is still pricing in a live contest rather than Blanche's near-certainty.
The current market price of 81% for Blanche appears significantly mispriced, overconfident given the unresolved committee vote and Tillis's explicit condition. My independent assessment of 68% reflects the 32% chance of Republican holdouts blocking advancement, which aligns more closely with Kalshi's conservative pricing than Polymarket's optimism. Lee Zeldin's 8% market share is inflated as a backup candidate, while DeSantis, Pirro, and Dhillon remain fringe options with minimal realistic paths unless Blanche is rejected outright.
Arguments
For
- Blanche already confirmed as Deputy AG in March 2025 with 52-46 vote, establishing prior Senate fitness judgment
- Trump's explicit demand that every Republican Senator confirm Blanche ASAP creates strong party pressure
- Acting AG tenure since April 2, 2026 provides operational continuity and border enforcement credibility
- TABS and border enforcement groups endorse Blanche as critical to continuing enforcement work
Against
- Sen. Tillis explicitly stated he won't vote to confirm unless Blanche meets Epstein survivors in next two weeks
- 1,200 DOJ alumni letter demanding rejection due to Trump ties and Epstein investigation handling
- Bar disciplinary referral for manipulating judicial process to secure Trump's tax immunity undermines integrity
- Tough questioning from Republicans during hearing suggests not all are convinced of his independence
Key drivers
- Sen. Thom Tillis's conditional vote requiring a meeting with Epstein survivors within two weeks
- Need for all Republican votes on Judiciary Committee to advance nomination
- Only three Republican votes can be lost on full Senate floor given Democratic opposition
- 1,200 DOJ alumni letter demanding rejection citing Trump ties and Epstein investigation concerns
Risk factors
- Sen. John Cornyn may also withhold support, compounding Tillis's holdout risk
- Bar disciplinary referral for improper judicial process manipulation to secure Trump's tax immunity
- Democratic senators uniformly opposing Blanche, eliminating any cross-party vote margin
- Epstein file controversy and subpoena attempts against journalists undermining DOJ independence claims
Scenarios
Best case
Blanche meets Epstein survivors within two weeks, Tillis and Cornyn both vote yes, committee advances nomination unanimously, and full Senate confirms with only two Republican defections, securing permanent AG role by August recess.
Most likely
Blanche meets survivors within deadline, Tillis votes yes but Cornyn hesitates, committee advances with 12-11 vote along party lines, full Senate confirms with three Republican defections, Blanche becomes permanent AG by late August 2026.
Worst case
Tillis refuses to meet survivors or Cornyn also holds out, committee vote fails by one Republican, nomination stalls indefinitely, Trump appoints Lee Zeldin or another alternative as acting AG while Blanche remains Deputy AG.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Todd Blanche | 68% | 81% |
| Lee Zeldin | 18% | 8% |
| Ron DeSantis | 6% | 2% |
| Jeanine Pirro | 4% | 2% |
| Harmeet Dhillon | 4% | 1% |
More from this day
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
How many World Cup matches will Trump attend?
AI97%MKT3%Edge+94Hidden GemTrump will attend 1 match (the 2026 World Cup Final), so the outcome '0 matches' is false. The market should resolve to No.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Which agencies will Trump eliminate?
AI98%MKT35%Edge+63Hidden GemUSAID looks overwhelmingly likely to count as eliminated under this market’s framing, because it has already been dismantled and absorbed into the State Department. I assign only a small residual chance that the market’s exact wording requires a stricter legal definition than the current facts satisfy.
- CompaniesKalshi1y
Robinhood funded customers in 2026
AI18%MKT77%Edge-59HypedRobinhood is unlikely to reach above 30.2 million funded customers in 2026, as the company reported only 27.7 million in May 2026 and needs an improbable 2.5 million new customers in the remaining seven months without evidence of a growth surge.