Who will be Trump's next Attorney General?
I assess Todd Blanche as the most likely nominee/confirmed Attorney General but not a slam — my independent probability for Blanche is 58%, with significant remaining chance for a Trump-aligned political pick (Zeldin/Harmeet) or a delayed/surprise selection.
Analysis
**Stage 1 — Blind analysis (IGNORE market prices):**
Todd Blanche is the incumbent acting Attorney General and has important structural advantages: incumbency, endorsements from influential Republican senators (Lindsey Graham) and state AGs urging confirmation, and a background that makes him broadly palatable to Senate Republicans and the career DOJ establishment. Historically, presidents often formalize acting AGs into permanent nominees when the acting AG is politically acceptable and reduces confirmation risk. Blanche's professional profile and the public push for a swift confirmation argue strongly in his favor.
At the same time, President Trump has repeatedly shown a willingness to prioritize personal loyalty and political advantage over conventional institutional quietude. That behavioral pattern raises the probability of a more explicitly political choice such as Lee Zeldin or Harmeet Dhillon, both of whom are trusted by Trump and would likely pursue more aggressive legal strategies that align with his priorities. Zeldin brings political stature and media/grassroots appeal; Dhillon brings direct litigation loyalty. Ron DeSantis or Jeanine Pirro are lower-probability but possible as disruptive political moves or bargaining chips.
Key timing considerations matter: if Trump wants the AG slot filled quickly (to signal toughness, secure an ally for ongoing legal/regulatory priorities, or stabilize DOJ leadership), Blanche is the natural, low-friction pick. If Trump is weighing political tradeoffs, rewarding loyalists, or considering 2028 electoral dynamics, he may delay or select a higher-profile partisan choice. There is also the confirmation calculus: Blanche likely faces less resistance in a GOP Senate; a politically polarizing pick would spur Democratic opposition and could fracture fragile intra-GOP support.
Balancing those forces, my independent assessment gives Blanche the plurality and likely majority chance but leaves meaningful probability for Zeldin and for a loyalist lawyer (Dhillon) — not enough to discount the risk of a surprise or delay.
**Stage 2 — Market calibration (LOOK at market prices now):**
Current market pricing heavily favors Blanche (market ~75%), with Zeldin, DeSantis, Pirro, and Dhillon collectively priced low. My independent probability (58% for Blanche) is materially lower than the market. Possible reasons the market might be overpricing Blanche:
- *Liquidity and crowd heuristics*: traders often overweight the acting official when early endorsements appear; a cascade effect can push the price above rational implied odds. - *Fast information amplification*: endorsements (Graham, state AGs) are visible and drive quick directional bets even if political-level decisions (Trump's personal preference) remain unsettled. - *Low-probability / long-shot outcomes underpriced*: political surprises (Zeldin, Dhillon, or a delayed/no announcement) are commonly under-bet by retail traders and algorithms seeking the path of least resistance. - *Aggregation inconsistencies across platforms*: the prompt references different markets (Polymarket, Kalshi, Gemini) with divergent leaderboards; arbitrage may be incomplete, leaving one aggregate price skewed.
Given those dynamics, I view the market as somewhat overconfident in Blanche. That does not mean Blanche is unlikely — 58% is a strong probability — but the market's 75% discounts Trump's demonstrated willingness to prioritize loyalty and political considerations, and it may underweight the possibility of a strategic delay or a loyalty-first pick.
Trading implication: if you accept my model, Blanche is a good favorite but not an auto-buy at current market levels; markets at ~75% leave little edge. Conversely, buying Zeldin/Dhillon at low prices could be attractive if you believe Trump's inclination toward a political loyalist is stronger than institutional continuity.
Arguments
For
- As acting AG, **Todd Blanche** minimizes nomination friction and is insulated from many political attacks — easier to confirm quickly.
- Endorsements from influential Republicans (e.g., Lindsey Graham) and support from state AGs create political momentum and signal Senate acceptance.
- Blanche's DOJ/AG-style credentials reduce the risk of hearings exposing partisan behavior, making him attractive to Senators focused on confirmations.
- A swift Blanche nomination serves institutional continuity and allows Trump to avoid intra-party rupture from a high-drama pick.
Against
- President Trump has a strong track record of selecting loyalists and outsiders; Blanche may be viewed as insufficiently partisan/loyal for Trump's priorities.
- High-profile political picks (Zeldin) or loyalist lawyers (Dhillon) could better satisfy Trump's immediate legal/political needs, making Blanche vulnerable.
- Public pressure to 'reward' allies or to pick a firebrand could outweigh the endorsements and push Trump toward a different choice.
- Deliberate delay — driven by political bargaining, litigation developments, or strategic timing — could allow other contenders to emerge or reduce Blanche's advantage.
Key drivers
- Incumbency and acting AG advantage (Blanche): ease of nomination and confirmation
- Trump's preference for personal loyalty vs. institutional steadiness
- Senate confirmation calculus (Republican cohesion and willingness to confirm a moderate/professional nominee)
- Public endorsements and pressure from Republican senators and state AGs
- Timing pressure — desire for rapid appointment vs. political bargaining/deliberation
Risk factors
- Trump's demonstrated unpredictability and tendency to reward political allies
- Potential political blowback or scandal that could derail a Blanche nomination
- Senate dynamics changing (e.g., intra-GOP opposition or need to placate a faction)
- Emergence of a late, high-profile outsider (e.g., DeSantis) as a political compromise or deal
- Market layering and crowding that hides real probability mass on 'no announcement' / delayed choices
Scenarios
Best case
Blanche is nominated quickly and confirmed within weeks — his incumbency, endorsements, and low-friction confirmation path produce an efficient transition to permanent AG. This stabilizes DOJ leadership and aligns the administration with a professionally credible AG who will pursue enforcement while avoiding extreme politicization.
Most likely
Blanche is the frontrunner and likely eventual nominee, but Trump weighs political benefits of a loyalist pick long enough that alternative candidates retain material probability. Expect a nomination within months, but not necessarily immediately; political jockeying could push the final decision into a drawn-out window.
Worst case
Trump bypasses Blanche in favor of a polarizing, loyalist pick (e.g., Zeldin or Dhillon) who triggers protracted confirmation fights and legal/political turbulence, or Trump delays indefinitely leading to prolonged uncertainty and high market volatility.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Todd Blanche | 58% | 75% |
| Lee Zeldin | 20% | 7% |
| Ron DeSantis | 6% | 2% |
| Jeanine Pirro | 4% | 1% |
| Harmeet Dhillon | 12% | 1% |
More from this day
- politicsPolymarketEnded
US forces enter Venezuela again by...?
AI12%MKT97%Edge-85HypedI assess a low probability (12%) that active US military personnel will physically enter Venezuelan land territory by June 30, 2026; the very short remaining window and high political/operational barriers make such an operation unlikely absent an urgent, unforeseen trigger.
- sportsPolymarketEnded
World Cup: Team to advance to Knockout Stages
AI62%MKT19%Edge+43Hidden GemI assess a moderately better-than-market chance that South Korea advances to the Round of 32, reflecting their historical strength and the favorable 2-of-3 group structure but tempered by uncertainty about their specific group draw, recent form, and match circumstances.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Who will Trump pardon?
AI3%MKT46%Edge-43HypedExtremely unlikely — I assess a low single-digit chance (~3%) that Barron Trump will receive a presidential pardon before Jan 21, 2029; pardons are legally possible absent conviction, but there is no factual or political path that makes this plausible at scale.