Who will be Trump's next Attorney General?
Given Blanche's formal nomination and his incumbency as acting Attorney General, I assign a high probability that Todd Blanche will be confirmed and be Trump's next Attorney General, though confirmation risks and political shocks leave nontrivial downside.
Analysis
**Stage 1 — Blind analysis (ignore market prices):**
Todd Blanche has been formally nominated and is already serving as acting Attorney General. That changes the problem from a speculative search for a candidate to a near-term confirmation contest. Historically, an administration's acting official who is then nominated enjoys advantages: institutional continuity, visibility, and the ability to demonstrate competence (or at least stability) in the role. The remaining hurdle is the Senate confirmation process: hearings, possible committee votes, and a floor vote. The probability of confirmation depends on three separate channels of risk — (a) the Senate majority and Republican unity, (b) any disqualifying revelations or scandals that emerge during vetting/hearings, and (c) procedural obstacles (filibuster rules do not apply to AG, but holds, intense media scrutiny and intra-party fights can delay or derail a nomination).
Balancing these elements, the baseline expectation is that a sitting acting AG formally nominated by the President has a strong path to confirmation unless there is a material change (major new revelations, a fissure in the President’s party, or a tactical trade in the Senate). I estimate those derailers as possible but not likely. Therefore, purely on fundamentals, I'm inclined to place a high probability on Blanche becoming the next Attorney General.
**Stage 2 — Market calibration:**
The market currently prices Todd Blanche at 64% and assigns smaller shares to other contenders (Zeldin 9%, DeSantis 4%, Bailey 2%, Dhillon 2%). My independent probability (78%) is meaningfully higher than the market's for Blanche. Possible reasons the market is discounting Blanche relative to my view:
- Market participants may be factoring in tail risks (surprise revelations, a sudden political calculation by Trump) that I consider unlikely. Markets sometimes over-weight the possibility of last-minute volatility. - Some portion of the market may expect a drawn-out confirmation fight that leads Trump to replace Blanche or compromise on a different nominee; I view that as a lower-probability route because Trump already installed Blanche as acting AG, signaling commitment. - Liquidity and trader composition can bias price: heavy short-term traders can push prices away from fundamentals, reflecting hedging flows rather than pure probability.
Given the above, the market's 64% is reasonable as a consensus but appears slightly conservative versus a nomination + incumbency-based assessment. That suggests a modest edge for people taking the market's 64% to back Blanche at my 78% view. Conversely, the market may be slightly overestimating the chance of an alternative winning through a late shock or intra-party revolt. My calibration leaves room for market rationales but still concludes Blanche is the clear favorite and likely eventual AG.
Overall verdict: *Blanche is the favorite with a strong but not certain path; confirmation is the key conditional step and the main source of downside risk.*
Arguments
For
- Formal nomination by the President removes primary uncertainty about Trump's preference and signals commitment.
- Serving as acting Attorney General provides incumbency benefits: institutional visibility, performance record, and control of narrative heading into hearings.
- Historical precedent: acting appointees who are nominated are often confirmed when the President's party controls the Senate or holds sufficient votes to pass nominees.
- Market and media framing already treat Blanche as front-runner, reducing the likelihood of last-minute collapse absent major new information.
Against
- Confirmation is not automatic; the Senate could delay, extract concessions, or conceivably vote down the nomination if intra-party dissatisfaction grows.
- Vetting and hearings can produce damaging new revelations or witness testimony that materially reduces support.
- Political bargaining or trade-offs could lead the administration to replace the nominee to secure other priorities or placate factions.
- High-profile legal controversies involving DOJ decisions while Blanche served as acting AG could politicize the confirmation and raise opposition.
Key drivers
- Formal nomination and incumbency as acting Attorney General (increases confirmation odds)
- Senate confirmation dynamics (majority party, intra-party unity, committee process)
- Potential for disqualifying revelations or political controversies during vetting/hearings
- Trump's continuing preference and political calculus (willingness to stick with Blanche vs. pivot)
Risk factors
- Uncovered legal or ethical issues during background checks/hearings that force withdrawal
- A fractious Senate or a small number of Republican defections blocking confirmation
- A sudden change in Trump's preference or a political trade that results in a different nominee
- External shocks (high-profile legal/political events) that make confirmation politically costly
Scenarios
Best case
Blanche sails through hearings, secures committee approval and a comfortable Senate vote, becoming confirmed AG quickly — continuity at DOJ and minimal political friction.
Most likely
Blanche is confirmed after a contentious but manageable hearing series; a few defections or drawn-out procedural steps cause delay, but no single event produces a sustained reversal of his frontrunner status.
Worst case
A damaging revelation or unexpected coalition of opposition senators forces Blanche to withdraw or be voted down; the White House pivots to an alternate nominee (e.g., Zeldin or another figure), creating a protracted process and potential short-term instability at DOJ.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Todd Blanche | 78% | 64% |
| Lee Zeldin | 10% | 9% |
| Ron DeSantis | 4% | 4% |
| Andrew Bailey | 3% | 2% |
| Harmeet Dhillon | 5% | 2% |
More from this day
- EconomicsKalshi3mo
When will Elon Musk become a trillionaire?
AI8%MKT91%Edge-83HypedI assess a low probability (~8%) that Elon Musk will be a trillionaire by 2027; current market pricing (~92% Yes) appears to be driven by speculative headlines rather than a realistic, near-term path to $1T in personal net worth.
- PoliticsKalshi18y
Which G7 leader will leave next?
AI30%MKT74%Edge-44HypedI assess a 30% independent probability that the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom will be the first G7 leader to leave office (blind to market prices).
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Who will Trump pardon?
AI8%MKT42%Edge-34HypedI assess a low probability that Barron Trump will receive a presidential pardon before Jan 21, 2029 — roughly 8% — because there is no public legal exposure for him and pardoning an immediate family member is politically costly and rare, though nonzero because presidential clemency is broad and Trump has signaled willingness to use pardons expansively.