Heisman Trophy Winner
Slight lean to Yes: Smith is still the betting favorite and his statistical case is strong. Ohio State’s shaky playoff profile and the final two games keep some downside, but the market already reflects that.
Analysis
2026-11-18 reports show Smith as the sportsbook favorite, with 80 catches, 1,317 yards, and 15 touchdowns. His recent production remains elite even with Ohio State’s quarterback changes.
The main risk is team context: Ohio State’s playoff outlook has weakened, which can affect Heisman voting. Still, Smith’s lead over Mensah and Dampier is sizable, and he has two chances left to reinforce it.
Arguments
For
- Smith leads the market and remains the statistical front-runner.
- He is still producing despite quarterback instability.
Against
- Ohio State’s losses may hurt his award narrative.
- Late-season quarterback candidates could close the gap.
Key drivers
- Smith's national receiving production and touchdown totals
- Ohio State's late-season games and voter narrative
Risk factors
- Injury or limited availability in the final two games
- A late surge by Mensah, Dampier, or Carr
Scenarios
Best case
If Smith dominates Nebraska and Michigan (November 21 and November 28), Yes rises to about 72%.
Most likely
Most likely Smith finishes as the favorite and wins, with Yes around 64%.
Worst case
If Smith is slowed or another contender surges in late November, Yes falls to about 52%.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Jeremiah Smith | 64% | 62% |
| Darian Mensah | 15% | 16% |
| Devon Dampier | 10% | 10% |
| CJ Carr | 6% | 4% |
| Gunner Stockton | 5% | 3% |
More from this day
- CryptoKalshiEnded
BTC price on Nov 19, 2026 at 5pm EST?
AI43%MKT76%Edge-33OvervaluedLeaning No: BTC sits above the cutoff now, but recent outflows and bearish momentum raise downside risk before the 5pm EST average. That leaves Yes a bit below the 46% market price.
- SportsKalshiTomorrow
South Africa vs Bangladesh
AI66%MKT93%Edge-27OvervaluedLeaning No: South Africa still trails in the first innings, and rain has already removed major playing time. The market’s 71% Yes looks a bit high versus the draw risk.
- politicsPolymarketEnded
What will Trump say during his trilateral meeting with Xi and Putin?
AI12%MKT29%Edge-17HypedSlight lean to No: 15+ mentions is a high bar for a single trilateral meeting, and Trump would need to repeat “China” or “Russia” very frequently in a short exchange on November 19.