Who will be the next Supreme Court justice?
Andrew Oldham is a credible but far from dominant contender: his conservative profile, Fifth Circuit seat, and Trump-aligned résumé keep him in the conversation, but there is no evidence he is actually selected or nominated yet. I put his independent chance of being the next Justice materially below the 18% market price.
Analysis
Oldham has attributes that make him a plausible Supreme Court pick if a Republican president gets a vacancy: he is relatively young, sits on the Fifth Circuit, clerked for Justice Alito, and has a strong conservative record that would appeal to the party’s legal base. Those factors keep him on shortlists and make him more plausible than many lower-court judges who lack national visibility or ideological alignment.
At the same time, the evidence provided does not show that he has been nominated, selected, or even clearly elevated to the top tier for this specific vacancy cycle. The broader field appears crowded, and several contenders have comparable or stronger political advantages depending on who controls the White House and Senate at the time of a vacancy; in Supreme Court selection, prior proximity to presidential networks and perceived confirmability often matter as much as judicial philosophy.
Compared with the current market price of 18%, the market looks somewhat optimistic on Oldham. I think the market is likely overweighting his ideological fit and underweighting the uncertainty of vacancy timing, presidential preference, and competition from other conservative judges; that said, he remains a live possibility rather than a long shot.
Arguments
For
- Arguments for Yes: Oldham’s conservative judicial record aligns well with the profile many Republican presidents seek for the Supreme Court.
- Arguments for Yes: His age and appellate bench experience make him a durable, conventional choice for a lifetime seat.
Against
- Arguments against Yes: The provided context shows no direct evidence that he has been nominated or chosen.
- Arguments against Yes: The field is competitive, and several rivals have similar ideological credentials with potentially stronger political appeal.
Key drivers
- Strong ideological fit for a conservative appointment.
- Current service on a federal appellate court gives him a conventional promotion path.
- Youth and appellate experience make him viable for a long-term Court seat.
- Political networks from Texas and the Trump orbit may help his standing.
Risk factors
- He has no visible nomination or selection signal in the provided evidence.
- Other contenders may be more personally connected to the relevant decision-makers or easier to confirm.
Scenarios
Best case
A Republican president faces a vacancy, wants a reliably conservative but not overly controversial nominee, and Oldham emerges as a confirmable Fifth Circuit judge with strong backing from legal conservative networks.
Most likely
Oldham remains a credible recurring contender in conservative SCOTUS speculation, but one of the other candidates or an outside name ultimately gets the nomination.
Worst case
The next vacancy is filled by someone with stronger personal ties to the White House or broader Senate support, leaving Oldham as a frequent shortlist name but never the final selection.
Outcomes
| Outcome | AI | MKT |
|---|---|---|
| Andrew Oldham | 12% | 18% |
| James Ho | 18% | 17% |
| D. John Sauer | 14% | 10% |
| Aileen Cannon | 6% | 10% |
| Amul Thapar | 10% | 9% |
More from this day
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
Harvey Weinstein prison time?
AI3%MKT97%Edge-94HypedWeinstein is far more likely than not to receive some prison time in this matter, because the available reporting indicates he still faces an active New York sentencing process and already has a substantial California sentence on the books. The market’s “No prison time” outcome looks very unlikely unless the remaining New York process collapses in an unexpected way and no custodial sentence is imposed by the deadline.
- pop culturePolymarketEnded
"Spider-Man: Brand New Day" Opening Weekend Box Office
AI93%MKT4%Edge+89Hidden GemThe market strongly favors a debut above $200 million, and the latest tracking is clustered well past that threshold. The main uncertainty is that one older Deadline-based estimate still sits below $200 million, but it now looks like the lower-probability outcome.
- PoliticsKalshi2y
Which agencies will Trump eliminate?
AI86%MKT30%Edge+56Hidden GemI assess a high probability that USAID will be eliminated in the practical, market-relevant sense during Trump’s term. The reporting shows the agency has already been effectively dismantled and folded into the State Department, though there is some legal ambiguity about whether a formal statutory abolition has fully occurred.